The best lunch spot in sister bay! Dine outside or take your food to go and picnic by the water! This place is so effortlessly cool. Love the bLT and my kids love the pizza rolls! We make sure we stop in for gelato at least once every time we’re in town. Also, the owners were featured on Wisconsin public television a few years ago. Make sure you check it out!
Overview
If you're in the mood for an unforgettable dining experience in Door County, a visit to Door County Creamery is a must. Nestled in the charming village of Sister Bay, Wisconsin, this delightful gem is located at 10653 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234, United States. Known for its fresh, artisanal cheeses and homemade delights, the restaurant offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere perfect for any occasion.
One of the first things you’ll notice upon entering the restaurant is the warm, rustic vibe. The charming décor creates an inviting space, whether you're there for a casual meal with friends or a special dinner with family. The friendly and attentive staff sets the tone for a relaxed yet intimate experience. They are always ready to help you explore the menu, making sure you enjoy every bite of the unique offerings.
The Door County Creamery menu is nothing short of impressive. Known for their specialty cheeses, the restaurant takes full advantage of the region’s rich dairy heritage, incorporating local products into each dish. The cheese boards are particularly popular, featuring an assortment of cheeses that range from creamy brie to sharp cheddar. You can pair them with fresh bread, crackers, and a variety of house-made preserves. It’s a great way to start your meal and get a taste of what this place is all about.
When it comes to the main courses, Door County Creamery doesn’t disappoint. From savory quiches to hearty sandwiches, there’s something for everyone. The signature sandwiches, made with fresh ingredients and served on locally baked bread, are particularly satisfying. A personal favorite is their grilled cheese, which takes this classic comfort food to a new level with a blend of unique cheeses and a perfect golden crust.
For those seeking a lighter option, the salads here are fresh and packed with flavor. The Mediterranean salad, for instance, is a refreshing combination of olives, feta, cucumber, and fresh greens. It’s the perfect balance of crisp and creamy. But if you’re craving something more indulgent, the quiches are definitely worth trying. They’re rich, flavorful, and perfectly baked, offering a comforting bite with every forkful.
If you have a sweet tooth, be sure to save room for dessert. The homemade ice cream is a standout, offering a variety of delicious flavors like honey lavender and salted caramel. For a true taste of Door County, try their famous cherry desserts. They’re a local specialty, and the cherry pie here is simply a must-try. The fruit is always fresh, bursting with sweetness in every bite.
Beyond the food, Door County Creamery is committed to using sustainable and locally sourced ingredients. This focus on quality not only elevates the dishes but also ensures that every meal is both delicious and responsible. The restaurant’s dedication to supporting local farmers and artisans is evident in every dish, from the locally sourced produce to the hand-crafted cheeses that are the heart of their menu.
In addition to its stellar menu, Door County Creamery offers a wonderful selection of drinks. Whether you’re looking for a fine wine to complement your meal or a refreshing craft beer, they have something to pair perfectly with any dish. Their wine list features local selections, many from nearby vineyards, giving you a true taste of Door County.
What makes Door County Creamery stand out is the sense of community. It’s not just about great food-it’s about the experience. Whether you’re visiting as a couple for a romantic evening or bringing the whole family for a casual lunch, there’s a warmth here that makes you feel right at home. The restaurant often hosts events and local gatherings, making it a true cornerstone of the Sister Bay community.
For those planning a trip to Door County, a visit to Door County Creamery is essential. With its delicious, locally sourced food, welcoming atmosphere, and commitment to quality, it’s no surprise that it’s become a favorite destination for both locals and visitors alike. Whether you're a cheese connoisseur or simply in search of a great meal, this place is sure to impress. So, next time you’re in the area, don’t miss the chance to enjoy all that this charming restaurant has to offer.
Good to know
From the business
âś“ Identifies as women-ownedService options
âś“ Outdoor seating âś“ On-site services âś“ Takeaway âś“ Dine-in âś“ DeliveryAccessibility
âś“ Wheelchair-accessible car park âś“ Wheelchair-accessible entrance âś“ Wheelchair-accessible seating âś“ Wheelchair-accessible toiletOfferings
âś“ Alcohol âś“ Beer âś“ Coffee âś“ Comfort food âś“ Organic dishes âś“ Small plates âś“ Vegetarian options âś“ WineDining options
âś“ Breakfast âś“ Brunch âś“ Lunch âś“ Dinner âś“ Catering âś“ Dessert âś“ SeatingAmenities
âś“ Toilet âś“ Wi-Fi âś“ Wi-FiCrowd
âś“ Family friendly âś“ LGBTQ+ friendly âś“ Transgender safe spacePlanning
âś“ Accepts reservationsPayments
âś“ Credit cards âś“ Debit cards âś“ NFC mobile payments âś“ Credit cardsChildren
âś“ Good for kids âś“ High chairs âś“ Kids' menuParking
âś“ Free of charge street parking âś“ Free parking lot âś“ ParkingPhotos
1 / 4
Location
Reviews
- No ratings yet 1394 reviews
The hot honey sandwich is THE perfect sandwich. The bread is crunchy and soft, the cheese is gooey and all over. It has a touch of heat with sweet and salty mixed in. I will think about it forever. Highly recommend! Turkey and Brie was also great if you want something a little more lowkey. Very nice patio that is dog friendly as well.
Honestly. The hot Sammy was the best sandwich I’ve had in my entire life. Warm meats with perfectly baked bread. I was shocked how good the food was. A bit pricier but you absolutely get what you pay for. Outstanding..
I didn’t walk into Door County Creamery with low expectations—quite the opposite. The place had a constant stream of people coming and going, which immediately told me it was somewhere worth checking out. After seeing the line move quickly and watching how many people left smiling, I figured there had to be a reason. I decided to try their coffee-flavored ice cream, and it was absolutely fantastic. The flavor was deep and authentic, with that perfect balance of roasted coffee taste and creamy sweetness. It wasn’t artificial or overly sugary—just smooth, rich, and perfectly crafted. Every bite felt like it was made with care and quality ingredients. The atmosphere inside was welcoming and upbeat. Even with how busy it was, the staff handled everything efficiently and with a smile. The shop was clean, inviting, and had that unmistakable Door County charm. Overall, this place exceeded my expectations and left a lasting impression. I’d go back in a heartbeat and recommend it to anyone looking for great ice cream and a genuinely enjoyable experience in Door County.
Delicious sandwich, soup and cookie! The turkey and Brie is magnificent! I could only eat half because it was so big, but excited to finish it late. The tomato basil soup was fabulous and the cookie was the best way to finish! The staff was so friendly and the cooks are polite and handsome.
This place is insanely good. It is a little pricey but you really get what you pay for. I think I’m truly going to dream about the turkey and Brie. Will definitely be going back next time we visit door county!
We love the creamery! It is a must stop when in Sister Bay; it’s very rare that we don’t make multiple stops there!